The “Unbearable Lightness” of Non-Linear Digital Editing - Text 3

In 1990, Murch would leave the Moviola and other film systems behind to embrace computer systems. His work on Coppola’s Godfather III (1990) — a good part of which was edited on a Montage system, one of the first truly “random-access, computer-controlled” editing systems[8] – marked his complete transition to digital systems.

Despite some reservations, by 1995, Murch was more or less convinced that the future of editing was electronic and digital. Since his first encounter with the CMX in 1968, his tendency had been “an enthusiastic but naive acceptance of electronics in the editing room – it seemed natural and inevitable to me then and, on a certain level, it does now”.[9] Still, he has “a respect for much of the inherent (and some of the unwitting) wisdom of mechanical editing, which has been slowly accumulated through many thousands of man-years of practical experience by the editing community”.[10] What many editors thought would be lost was “the plain fact of film’s physical existence – that the image is actually captured, chemically, on celluloid”.[11] This was significant to Murch, who thus described the relation between the materiality of film and the ephemeral nature of the cinematic experience:

What we are communicating through film is so insubstantial – fleeting emotions patterned with beams of colored light and waves of sound – that it is somehow restoratively balancing to be able to actually hold a frame of film in one’s hand. There is a wonderful alchemy in this: that hydrocarbons and silver and iron and various colored dyes, plus intangible time, can transmute themselves into the stuff of dreams.[12]

To Murch, given the fundamentally insubstantial nature of the cinematic experience, it is important that there be a stage in its production when something material could be grasped, when manipulation could be felt directly, when the medium could be confronted in its concrete tangibility, its materiality. “[C]ompared to the stream of a computer’s weightless electrons and ghostly digits, film is gravity itself”.[13] While he admits that digital editing offers unparalleled speed and flexibility, he wonders if, before the process is comprehensively digitized,

we cannot use the lingering grace period to take another look at film’s physicality and find a way to incorporate, somehow, various simulations of the best of that physicality into the new systems. A reel of film is obstinately the way it is and no other – unless you actually rearrange the matter out of which it is made – and there is an anchoring, inertial value in that which the fluttering electrons, for all their nervous power, do not share.[14]

The contrast between film editing and digital editing may not be as significant as Murch suggests, though. The difference may not be reducible to that between hydrocarbons and electrons. The “intangibility” of the cinematic experience is not obviously related, in any clear-cut manner, to the specific physical compounds used in the production of the imagery. In both cases, material systems are used to create images to be projected or displayed on screens, as the basis for an imaginative, conceptual, interpretive experience on the part of the viewer. While the differences between the systems of production may or may not be felt acutely by those creating the imagery, it is not clear that they are felt at all by those viewing it.

Document type (medium)

Born-digital text

Publisher

TECHNÈS

Date available

2022

Language

en

Format

text/html

Rights

© TECHNÈS, 2022. Some rights reserved.

License

Identifier

ark:/17444/94054p/4159

Record last modification date

2022-04-25
2022-12-15

Export