Cinematic Perception: An Encounter Between Human Metabolic Rhythm and the Moving Image - Text 3
In his studies, Wertheimer also refutes the theory of retinal persistence. According to him, the perception of moving images cannot be explained solely by a biological property of the eye and must also involve psychological and/or neural processes. As he concludes: “It is not sufficient to draw upon pure peripheral processes in relation to a single eye: we must have recourse to processes which lie behind the retina.”[9] Other researchers, such as Frederick A. Talbot, have conducted studies that combine the theory of retinal persistence with a neurological approach to the phenomenon. According to this author, the persistence required for this fusion effect would occur in the brain rather than in the retina.[10] Psychologist Hugo Münsterberg similarly proposes that the brain itself fills in the missing patterns between successive images.[11]
Among neuroscientific research, a new understanding of the phenomenon emerged in the 1970s. Scientists compared the neural processes involved in the perception of real motion with those enabling the perception of movement when viewing a sequence of still images. According to the experiments of Paul Kolers, Marguerite Biederman-Thorson, John Thorson and G. David Lange, the succession of images containing subtle, spatially close differences would be processed by the brain in the same way as real motion.[12] Years later, Joseph and Barbara Anderson named this phenomenon “short-range apparent motion.”[13] According to their study, the retina also plays a role in capturing variations in brightness and color; this information is then transmitted to the brain and transformed into sequences of brightness that enable the computation of motion and depth. The Andersons further observe, however, that this perceptual mechanism does not account for the phi phenomenon. Since Wertheimer’s experiment involves images with strongly marked differences, they argue that it could not be processed by the brain as realistic motion.
Toward “Continuity Editing”
Another factor has also shaped the rhythm specific to the seventh art since its institutionalization: editing, which in contemporary cinema most often takes the form of so-called “continuity editing.” This form of editing derives its name from the appearance of fluidity produced by the succession of shots for spectators, and its practice is therefore intimately connected to the biological functioning of human vision. Indeed, this type of editing appears to follow the temporal and instinctive logic of the gaze: in everyday life, when the eye is confronted with a large amount of visual information, it scans “a scene or an image in a series of successive fixations, selecting those areas of the visual array that yield the most information.”[14] Moreover, the duration of sustained attention during these fixations follows a temporal pattern. Since the 1960s, the average shot length appears to correspond to the span of attention normally devoted by the eye to a visual stimulus.[15] In practice, editors working within an continuity editing style would therefore have instinctively applied the natural logic of the gaze in constructing the visual dynamics of cinematic works. Several theories of optical perception indeed attribute a constructive activity to the human visual system, which is understood to operate through the cognitive assembly of meaningful patterns identified within the visual field. The research conducted by Zacks, Speer, Swallow and Maley further demonstrated the following:
Cuts that simply changed viewpoint within a scene while maintaining continuity of time, location, and action were not identified as [narrative] boundaries […] by brain activity. Instead, such cuts produced activity in cortical areas associated with attentional control and task switching.[16]
This capacity for neural adaptation to cuts can be readily explained through recent studies. Although we evolve within a continuous environment, our perception appears to process what we see quite differently. As the researcher James E. Cutting explains, our visual device produces a mode of perception similar to that of an edited film narrative. The phenomenon known as the “ocular saccade”[17] is said to be responsible for this. Framing our everyday visual experience, it consists of the rapid movement of the eyes from one fixation point to another. During this ocular movement, our perception of images is effectively reduced, and we do not retain in memory the elements traversed by the gaze. This visual interruption is referred to by psychologists Benno Erdmann and Raymond Dodge as “saccadic suppression.”[18] Thus, just as we naturally accept a disrupted visual flow, the transition from one shot to another within a logic of spatial continuity neither interrupts nor disrupts the natural course of perception. The same applies to changes in point of view. In the case of shot/reverse-shot editing, the points of fixation and attention correspond to the characters’ spoken interventions. Yet it does not appear cognitively disturbing for the camera suddenly to be positioned in front of or behind them. This observation supports the phenomenon of “inattentional blindness” discussed in a study conducted by Daniel T. Levin and Daniel J. Simons. According to their findings, the appearance and disappearance of elements within an image may escape our perception, provided that they are not the primary focus of our attention.[19]
Thus, cuts employed within the framework of continuity editing do not produce, for spectators, the perception of an increased rhythm. Much like the perception of movement generated by the succession of still images, such cuts extend the natural logic of the gaze and align our perception with that of a real scene. It is highly likely, however, that less conventional forms of editing—such as the use of the jump cut—affect the brain quite differently and exert a much stronger influence on our perception of cinematic rhythm.