Journalism - Text 2
The distinction between the authenticity of an amateur recording (as clumsy as it may be) on the one hand and journalistic objectivity on the other also echoes the head-to-head battle between the surveillance strategies of state apparatuses and the tactics and counter-measures adopted by citizens.[3] Steve Mann, in response to the surveillance techniques spreading throughout our cities, has proposed the concept of “sousveillance” to describe the ways in which citizens can undermine the hierarchy imposed by the state surveillance apparatus by adopting the means to document how this apparatus operates themselves. Sousveillance thus regularly uses action cameras because of their ability to capture images without interruption, independently and discreetly. Sousveillance in all its forms (from the cameras on smartphones to traditional action cameras, GoPro and the rest, by way of personal security cameras) has, moreover, made it possible to highlight the extent of the violence committed by the police still today against racialized people.
Police body cams
In response to these violent acts and to account for their actions, police forces have decided to adopt the tactics of sousveillance themselves by equipping their officers with body cams (cameras worn on the police officer’s head or torso). This reversal of citizen sousveillance tactics – taken up by police forces and reinvested in disciplinary strategies – seeks to exploit the authenticity which too often is seen as inherent in the images taken from action cameras. Images produced by the camera-equipped body represent a lived experience of that body, but this experience can still be doctored or simply subject to different interpretations. In fact, the video from an action camera is fragmentary, as Adjungierte Dislokationen illustrates so effectively. This is precisely what Caren Myers Morrison suggests, with regard to the use of video by the police:
Despite its claims to realism, any video camera footage will necessarily be fragmentary. Whatever direction a camera is pointing in, it will “eliminate what is above, below, and behind the camera.” It will record one thing, and not another, which is blocked, or too far away, or too poorly lit to be visible. There are also temporal limitations to video, which will miss what happened before the device was turned on, as well as what happened after the recording ended. Because it may only show fragments of what is happening, video can easily be misread.[4]
An image’s authenticity is also dependent on the interpretative communities in which it circulates, each characterized by certain biases which will influence the image’s reception. On this topic, Myers Morrison discusses Seth Stoughton’s study of how different images used by the police are interpreted. In one video in particular, the image produced by a body cam shows a man dressed in red frantically gesturing in front of the filmer’s body. Myers Morrison reports that the results of a survey done by The New York Times in response to these videos show that at least 41 % of the survey participants described the images as “somewhat threatening” and 32 % described them as “very threatening.”[5]
