Introduction - Text 1
Editing seems to have changed with the advent of “digital” cinema. Before dedicated non-linear video and digital editing systems and software started to appear at the end of the 1960s, the basic apparatus for film editing had remained more or less unaffected by cinema’s many dramatic technological developments. Various editing styles had emerged, in different national cinemas at different times, as filmmakers explored the expressive possibilities of arranging and combining moving imagery and sound. But these were all realized through basically the same procedures of cutting and splicing tangible film. Some particular tools became more mechanically complex over the years – as the Moviola complemented and refined work that had hitherto only been done with scissors, before being practically replaced by “flatbed” editing systems – but editing remained the technically simple process of cutting film into pieces, and assembling them with glue or tape.
Now, editing is digital. As such, it seems wholly different than the physical technique of film editing. This change to the material essence of filmmaking transforms a technically simple physical technique into a complex, virtual, computer-mediated process. What had characterized film as a medium – the material intransigence, solidity, tangibility that characterized the physical qualities of the film strip – necessarily imposed limitations on editing. Indeed, film editing, according to its minimal definition as connecting one strip of film with another, emerged – in a certain respect, and first of all – as a result of the limitations of the technical apparatus of the cinema. It was, for example, a necessary procedure for making a film longer than the reel of stock that could fit into a camera. But, even from the start, it has also been understood as an important expressive technique, by which complex narratives could be constructed, meaning generated, symbols created, and ideas communicated. In this respect, editing has seemed an indispensable aspect of filmmaking as an art, and as an expressive and communicative undertaking.
But now, the technical limitations from which aesthetic and expressive effects had once been derived have been overcome. It is not any longer the length of the "film-strip" that governs editing but rather the space (or amount of storage) of the computer hard-disk. Thus the very concept of montage is effectively transformed from a fundamentally temporal technique to a spatial one, as Lev Manovich,[1] David Norman Rodowick[2] and others have remarked. Digital technologies may well have made editing dispensable as a stylistic technique, for it is arguably much easier now, in the digital era, to make films that consist of a long, uninterrupted single shot. In that respect “digital editing” may, paradoxically, be understood as the basis for the possibility of not editing, for the severing of editing as a technical requirement from montage as an expressive style. It is worth noting, though, that while many have been made recently, the single-shot film has by no means become a dominant or even significant trend.
But if montage is understood as an abstract, conceptual structure applied to the tangible material of film, then the effect of digital editing can be seen as the triumph of the conceptual over the physical, the full imposition of artistic intention in a medium that had supposedly been defined by its autonomous, causal origins in a material, technological process. Digital editing seems to have brought the entire identity of the cinema into question.
This parcours explores the impact of digital technologies on the practices and techniques of editing. It considers the proliferation in the digital era of feature-length “single-shot” films, it examines testimony of some editors and filmmakers contending with the introduction of digital editing, and looks at some of the technological transformations that editing underwent before the digital era. As specific examples, to investigate these transformations, three versions of Ben-Hur, from three different moments in the history of “analog” editing, are considered and then compared to a recent “digital” Ben-Hur. It also considers the enduring impact on the cinema of, first, video editing, and then digital editing – which allow filmmakers to do much more than “merely edit.”
