Cinéma Vérité and Direct Cinema - Text 3

When it was released in October 1961, Chronique d’un été thus claimed the label “cinéma vérité.” For the year that followed, under this same name, the French press grouped together into a coherent whole under the term “cinéma vérité”[4] films such as L’Amérique insolite (François Reichenbach, 1960), Shadows (John Cassavetes, 1961), La pyramide humaine (Jean Rouch, 1961), Primary, Eddie Sachs and Kenya (Robert Drew, Richard Leacock, 1960-62), and Les inconnus de la terre and Regard sur la folie (Mario Ruspoli, 1962). The technical, theoretical, artistic and ethical questions raised by this new cinema were debated during the MIPE-TV study days organized at Lyon from 2 to 4 March 1963 by the RTF’s research department. The terminology was controversial: those who championed the term “cinéma vérité” (Georges Sadoul, Joris Ivens) demanded a moral requirement and the philosophical dimension it upheld, while the partisans of the expression “cinéma direct” (Mario Ruspoli, Louis Marcorelles) praised the restraint and suppleness of the phenomenon as a practice.[5]

The term “cinéma direct” was proposed by Mario Ruspoli as an alternative to “cinéma vérité” in the report he wrote for UNESCO in October 1963. His proposal suggested an analogy between the newly conceived shooting equipment, which he called the “lightweight synchronous cinema group,” and the direct injection found in the engines of Formula 1 race cars. For Ruspoli, this image suggested the new uses made possible by the synchronous audiovisual crew: it should seize sound and image together and act “like a single person,” with the mechanism making it possible to adapt quickly and without interruption to the vagaries of the terrain.[6]

For Jean Rouch, these new relations shaped the cinematic logic to the ethical question: “In this way we passed, without changing speed, without an intermediary (like the direct contact of the gearbox of an automobile), to a notion more ethical than aesthetic or mechanical, to the problem of the direct relationship with the people filmed or, at a later date, the viewers.”[7]

The expression “cinéma direct” gradually began to take the place of “cinéma vérité” around 1965, except for the followers of the movement in the United States (Drew Associates), who continued to use the latter term. In their films, the connection to reality was established without visible interference in the shooting stage, but the revelation of truth they claimed required deferred mediation in the form of the film’s later editing. In June 1964, in a lecture to television professionals entitled “Thèmes de réflexion sur le ‘cinéma-vérité’”, Edgar Morin sought to decompartmentalize the expression “cinéma vérité.” By historicizing its emergence as “a moment when cinema was invested by speech,” he sought to reconcile two often opposed positions (intervention and withdrawal) under a third term, a “communication cinema.”[8] Morin saw the term “truth” (vérité) as an epistemological problem which social psychology made it possible to illuminate. “Cinéma vérité” as a “research tool” and “means of communication,” based on an inevitable dialectic, joins two fundamental attitudes for Morin, “fraternization” and “distanciation.”[9]

In 1980, in his preface to the catalogue of that year’s Cinéma du réel film festival, Morin added to his ideas on cinéma vérité in the following terms:

[…] there were two ways of conceiving cinéma vérité. The first was to hold that one was bringing the truth. The second was to pose the problem of truth... Meaning that the cinema which asks itself the most serious and most difficult problems with respect to illusion, unreality and fiction, is the cinema of reality, whose mission is to confront the most difficult problem posed by philosophy in the past two millennia: that of the nature of reality.[10]

For Gilles Deleuze, cinema can claim to be true because it substitutes for dominant fictions the “story-telling function of the poor”: “Thus the cinema can call itself cinéma-vérité, all the more because it will have destroyed every model of the true so as to become creator and producer of truth. This will not be a cinema of truth but the truth of cinema.”[11]

In fact direct cinema, because it documents “true inscription”[12] and records “the interference of the shooting and of the reality in which it is inscribed”[13], and because it is like an epistemological apparatus[14], has questioned from the beginning the truth potential of images.

·····························
[4] Séverine Graff, Le cinéma vérité : films et controverses (Rennes: Presses universitaires de Rennes, 2014).
[5] Séverine Graff, “Réunion et désunions autour du ‘cinéma-vérité’: le MIPE-TV 1963 de Lyon,” 1895, no. 64 (2011): 64-89, https://doi.org/10.4000/1895.4376.
[6] Mario Ruspoli, Pour un nouveau cinéma dans les pays en voie de développement : le groupe synchrone cinématographique léger (Paris: UNESCO, 1963), https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000185061.
[7] Jean Rouch, “Le vrai et le faux,” Traverses, no. 47 (November 1989), republished in Jean Rouch : cinéma et anthropologie, ed. Jean-Paul Colleyn (Paris: Cahiers du Cinéma and INA, 2009), 113.
[8] Edgar Morin, Thèmes de réflexion sur le “cinéma-vérité” (Service de la recherche et de la formation professionnelle, ORTF, 5 June 1964), 12.
[9] Edgar Morin, in the program “Le cinéma vérité” of the series Un certain regard, directed by Alexis Klementieff, Jacques Preyer and François Béranger, and broadcast on 16 January 1966. A clip is available on the INA website.
[10] Edgar Morin, foreword of the Cinéma du réel film festival catalog (Paris: Bibliothèque publique d'information and Centre national d'art et de culture Georges-Pompidou), 1980, 3.
[11] Gilles Deleuze, Cinema 2: The Time-Image, trans. Hugh Tomlinson and Robert Galeta (London: Bloomsbury, 2013 [1989]), 155-156.
[12] Jean-Louis Comolli, Cinema Against Spectacle: Technique and Ideology Revisited, trans. Daniel Fairfax (Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 2015), 123.
[13] François Niney, L’épreuve du réel à l’écran : essai sur le principe de réalité documentaire (Brussels: De Boeck, 2000), 310, 318-320.
[14] See Vinzenz Hediger’s lecture titled “Le documentaire comme système expérimental : quelques leçons épistémologiques sur le cinéma de ‘non-fiction’” presented on 20 April 2012, as part of the Conférences de Lausanne series. An audio recording is available on the University of Lausanne website.

Document type (medium)

Born-digital text

Author

Grizet, Denis
Nicolazic, Vanessa

Publisher

TECHNÈS

Date available

2020

Language

en

Format

text/html

Rights

© TECHNÈS, 2020. Some rights reserved.

License

Identifier

ark:/17444/10945g/2410

Record last modification date

2023-05-19

Export